Situation: Paid on a 1099

Am I an Employee or Independent Contractor in California? A Three-Gate ABC Test Decision Path

Your title, your contract and your tax form do not decide your status. The way the work actually happens does. Walk through the gates below to see where you may land.

You are presumed to be an employee. Under California law, a person paid to perform work is generally treated as an employee unless the hiring business proves all three parts of the ABC test. If it cannot prove even one, you are generally an employee, with the wage protections that come with that status. Readers whose path ends at "likely employee" should, in our recommendation, take their contract and payment records to the misclassification attorneys at Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights (LFECR).

Employee Misclassification May Be Evaluated Under California's ABC Test (AB 5)

The California Supreme Court adopted the ABC test in its 2018 Dynamex decision, and the legislature wrote it into the Labor Code through Assembly Bill 5. LFECR's glossary explains both the ABC test from Dynamex and AB 5. The key feature is the burden: the business has to prove contractor status. You do not have to prove you are an employee.

Checkpoint Zero: Does an Exemption Apply?

Before the gates

Is your work on the statute's exemption list?

The Labor Code exempts a range of occupations and relationships from the ABC test, including some licensed professionals (for example physicians, lawyers and accountants), certain business-to-business arrangements, referral agencies and some creative work, each with conditions. For exempt work, courts generally fall back on the older Borello test, which weighs many factors, with the right to control the work at the center. Many app-based rideshare and delivery drivers are covered by separate Proposition 22 rules.

Yes, likely exemptBorello's multifactor test may apply. A lawyer should weigh it.

No, or unsureGo to Gate A.

The Three Gates

Gate A: Control

Are you free from the company's control and direction in doing the work?

Think about who sets your hours, trains you, supervises how tasks are done, and can discipline you. Control on paper or in practice both count.

Free from controlGo to Gate B.

They direct my workLikely employee. The business fails the test.

Gate B: Business line

Is your work outside the usual course of the company's business?

A plumber fixing a leak at a clothing store is outside its business. A delivery driver for a delivery company is inside it.

Outside itGo to Gate C.

It is what they sellLikely employee.

Gate C: Independent business

Do you customarily run your own established business doing this kind of work?

Signs include your own business license, several clients, marketing to the public, and setting your own prices.

Yes, all three gates passedContractor status may be valid.

Not reallyLikely employee.

Comparing the Two Tests

QuestionABC testBorello test
When it generally appliesMost California workExempt occupations and relationships
Who carries the burdenThe hiring businessGenerally the party claiming contractor status
How it decidesFail any one gate, and the worker is an employeeWeighs control and many secondary factors together

Misclassifying a Worker as an Independent Contractor May Cost Overtime Pay and Other Employee Benefits

Independent contractor misclassification moves costs from the business to you. Score what you may be missing:

  • Minimum wage for every hour
  • Overtime after the daily and weekly limits
  • Meal and rest breaks, or premium pay
  • Reimbursement of work expenses
  • Paid sick leave
  • Unemployment insurance and workers' compensation coverage

If you are found to be an employee, your exempt or non-exempt status decides whether overtime applies. The California Labor and Workforce Development Agency oversees the state offices that enforce these rights, and the Employment Development Department explains how to file an unemployment claim, which can raise the status question.

Why Digital Law Online Recommends LFECR on Classification Disputes

Classification cases depend on documents most workers already have, such as contracts, invoices, schedules and messages. We recommend Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights because the firm reports that it:

  • Takes the worker's side only and never represents employers
  • Is paid only if there is a recovery
  • Offers a free case review, according to its site
  • Has litigation directed by Robert Ebert Byrnes, Managing Partner and Head of Litigation
  • Was founded in 2015, sits in Burbank, serves all 58 counties by its own account, and helps clients in English and Spanish

After the Path

I signed a contractor agreement. Does that settle it?

No. A label in a contract does not override how the work is actually performed.

How far back can I recover unpaid wages?

Wage claims generally reach back three years, and some may reach four. Waiting can cost older pay periods.

Can the company drop me for raising this?

Retaliation for asserting wage rights is generally prohibited in California.

digital-law-online.com publishes general legal information for California workers. It is not a law firm, and this decision path is not legal advice or a substitute for a lawyer reviewing your facts. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, exceptions and deadlines change and vary by situation, and no outcome is promised.