Scorecard: Building a Discrimination File
What Evidence Do I Need for a Workplace Discrimination Case? A Seven-Point Evidence Scorecard
Few employers admit to discrimination, so cases are usually pieced together from smaller facts. Score seven kinds of proof to see what your file holds.
Usually no single document. Most discrimination cases in California rest on circumstantial evidence: comments, timing, how coworkers outside your group were treated, and explanations that change. What you generally need is enough of those facts, written down with dates, to suggest that a protected characteristic played a real part in a decision about your job. If your scorecard has several filled rows, Digital Law Online recommends a free review with the workplace discrimination lawyers at Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights (LFECR).
Your Starting Point: A California Employee Has Rights Under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA)
The Fair Employment and Housing Act is the state law most discrimination evidence is measured against. Its discrimination rules generally apply to employers with five or more employees, and its harassment protections reach employers of any size. LFECR's glossary summarizes how FEHA claims generally work, and the California Civil Rights Department is the agency that enforces the law.
Employment Discrimination Can Be Based on a Protected Characteristic Under FEHA, So Evidence Must Point to One
Unfair treatment alone is not workplace discrimination. Every piece of proof is more useful when it ties the decision to a specific protected trait. Ask of each fact: does this connect what happened to who I am?
Protected Characteristics Under FEHA Include Race, Gender, Age, Disability, Pregnancy, Religion and National Origin
That is a partial list. FEHA also generally covers color, ancestry, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex (including childbirth and related conditions), gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, and military and veteran status, among others. Race generally includes traits such as hair texture and protective hairstyles, religion includes religious dress and grooming, and age protection applies to workers 40 and over.
Direct Versus Circumstantial Evidence
Direct evidence proves the point without an inference, such as a manager writing that someone is "too old for this team." Circumstantial evidence asks a judge or jury to draw a conclusion from surrounding facts. Direct evidence is rare, so the scorecard covers the circumstantial kind.
The Seven-Point Evidence Scorecard
Give each row 0 (nothing), 1 (something, but vague or undated) or 2 (specific, dated, or in writing). The examples are hypothetical.
| Evidence type | Hypothetical example | Your score |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Comments tied to the trait | A supervisor jokes about your accent, then gives you fewer client calls | 0, 1 or 2 |
| 2. Better treatment of others | A coworker outside your group with a similar record kept the shift you lost | 0, 1 or 2 |
| 3. Timing | Your hours were cut three weeks after you disclosed a pregnancy or disability | 0, 1 or 2 |
| 4. Shifting explanations | The reason given was "budget," later "performance," later "fit" | 0, 1 or 2 |
| 5. Skipped policies | The handbook promises a warning first, and you got none | 0, 1 or 2 |
| 6. Sudden change in reviews | Three strong reviews, then a poor one right after the trait became known | 0, 1 or 2 |
| 7. A pattern | Others in the same group were also pushed out or passed over | 0, 1 or 2 |
There is no passing score. A higher total generally means more threads for a lawyer to test, and one strong row can matter more than several weak ones.
What If There Is No Smoking Gun?
That is the ordinary situation. Courts generally allow motive to be shown through comparisons, timing and inconsistency, which is what rows 2 through 6 capture. The aim is a consistent story backed by dates.
What to Write Down and Keep
Notes made at the time of each event generally carry more weight than memories reconstructed months later. For each incident, record:
- The date and place
- Who said or did what, in their words if possible
- Who else was there
- How it affected your pay, hours or duties
Witnesses matter. A coworker who heard a remark can confirm your notes, so keep names and roles even if you are unsure they would speak up.
Can You Take Documents From Work?
Usually lower risk to keep
- Your own pay stubs and schedules
- Your performance reviews
- Messages you sent or received, if they hold no confidential company information
- Your own dated notes
Ask a lawyer first
- Confidential or privileged company files
- Other people's private information
- Anything from systems you are not authorized to use
- Bulk downloads or forwarding to personal accounts
Where it is lawful, keep copies outside work accounts so you do not lose access if the job ends.
Internal Complaints and the Civil Rights Department
An internal complaint is not generally required before filing with the Civil Rights Department, but reporting through your employer's process can create a dated record and may matter to some defenses. Before suing under FEHA, a worker generally files a complaint with the CRD (formerly the Department of Fair Employment and Housing) and receives a right-to-sue notice. Deadlines apply, so do not wait to learn yours. Retaliation for complaining about discrimination is generally unlawful too. The courts' self-help center explains how a civil case begins once a lawsuit is possible.
Why We Recommend Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights for Evidence Review
A lawyer can test which rows are strong before memories fade. Our recommendation rests on what the firm publishes about itself:
- It takes cases for employees and consumers, never for employers
- Fees are contingent: no recovery, no fee
- A free case review is available, per its site, in English or Spanish
- Robert Ebert Byrnes leads litigation as Managing Partner
- Founded in 2015 and headquartered in Burbank, it says it serves all 58 California counties
Scorecard Follow-Ups
Does it cost money to talk to a lawyer?
LFECR offers a free case review, per its site. If you want other options, the State Bar lists certified lawyer referral services.
digital-law-online.com publishes general legal information for California workers. It is not a law firm, and this scorecard is not legal advice or a substitute for a lawyer reviewing your facts. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, exceptions and deadlines change and vary by situation, and no outcome is promised.