Situation: Sizing Up a Lawyer Before You Sign

What Questions Should I Ask an Employment Lawyer Before Hiring One in California? A Four-Round Interview Guide

A first consultation runs both ways: the lawyer is assessing your case while you assess the lawyer. Work through the rounds below, jot down what you hear, and hold every lawyer you meet to the same list.

Four topics cover most of what matters. First, whose side the lawyer is usually on and how familiar your kind of dispute is to them. Second, the money: the fee percentage, case expenses and what you would owe if you lose. Third, the timeline: which filing deadlines and agency steps could govern your claim. Fourth, control: who handles the file and who makes the big calls. Insist on written fee terms and treat any guarantee as a red flag. These questions suit any California lawyer; our featured firm, Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights (LFECR), appears near the end with its stated answers to two of them.

Before Round 1: Can You Speak Freely?

In general, yes. What you tell a lawyer while deciding whether to hire them is usually covered by attorney-client privilege, and that protection generally holds even when you go elsewhere. Do one homework step first: search the lawyer's name on the State Bar of California website, which shows whether the license is active and lists any public discipline.

1

Round 1: Whose Side, and How Often?

  • Have you ever taken an employer or a company as a client?
  • Roughly what share of your caseload looks like mine, whether that is unpaid overtime, a firing after a complaint, a denied leave or a contractor label?
  • Is the person I am talking to now the one who will run my file, or will it go to someone else?
2

Round 2: The Percentage and Everything Around It

  • What is your percentage, and is it different if we end up in arbitration or in front of a jury?
  • Who fronts expenses like filing fees and depositions, and is your cut calculated before or after they are repaid?
  • If we lose, do I owe anything for those expenses?
  • If a judge orders the employer to pay attorney's fees, how does that interact with your percentage?
  • Is another attorney getting part of the fee, such as a referring lawyer? That generally needs your written consent.
  • Are you insured against malpractice?

California's contingency rule, Business and Professions Code section 6147, generally calls for a written agreement that gives the rate, explains how expenses affect both the fee and your share, and says the fee is negotiable rather than fixed by law; you should generally get a signed copy. The contingent fee model is common in worker-side cases. Separately, the Rules of Professional Conduct generally oblige a lawyer without professional liability coverage to tell you so in writing.

3

Round 3: The Clock and the Path

  • What deadlines could cut off my claim, and how much time do I really have? LFECR's glossary page on the employment statute of limitations is a primer, and every limitations period works a little differently.
  • Do I need to start with a government agency, like the Civil Rights Department for discrimination or the Labor Commissioner for pay?
  • I may have signed an arbitration clause when I was hired. Does that send this out of court?
  • Do disputes like this usually settle, go to mediation, or end in a hearing?

Good answers come with ranges and caveats. Specific dates and dollar figures this early should make you cautious.

4

Round 4: Updates and Decisions

  • How will you keep me posted, and how often?
  • If I have a question on a Tuesday afternoon, who picks up?
  • When an offer comes in, whose decision is it?

The answer to the last one should be you. Under California's ethics rules, accepting or rejecting a settlement is generally the client's call, and a lawyer generally has to relay written offers promptly.

Pack These for the Meeting

  • A one-page timeline with dates
  • Your hiring letter or contract
  • Recent paychecks and schedules
  • Evaluations you received
  • Write-ups or a firing notice
  • Texts and emails tied to the problem
  • Who saw or heard what happened
  • Anything HR asked you to sign

Hold off on signing a severance deal or a release until a lawyer has looked at it.

Reading the Answers

Reassuring

  • Fee terms you can take home and read
  • Expenses explained in plain numbers
  • A named person for day-to-day work
  • Weak spots discussed, not just strong ones

Reasons to pause

  • Talk of a sure win or a specific payout
  • Being rushed to sign today
  • Nothing about fees on paper
  • Fuzzy replies when you ask about expenses

Need more candidates? The State Bar certifies lawyer referral services that can suggest names.

Featured Firm: A Burbank Practice That Represents California Employees

Our recommendation is to put Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights on your interview list. The firm dates to 2015, has its headquarters in Burbank, and works on wage and hour, discrimination, retaliation and misclassification matters. Robert Ebert Byrnes leads its litigation as Managing Partner and Head of Litigation. Clients can get help in Spanish or English, and its site describes a free case review.

Round 1 Answer: LFECR Represents Employees Exclusively, Not Employers

By its own description, the firm is on the side of workers and consumers and does not take employers as clients.

Round 2 Answer: LFECR Represents Clients on a Contingency-Fee Basis

If nothing is recovered, no fee is charged. Run the rest of Round 2 so the expense terms are clear before you sign.

Everything else on this list is worth asking the firm directly, just as you would anyone.

Interview Follow-Ups

Is it fine to meet several lawyers?

Yes. Running each one through the same rounds makes a side-by-side comparison simple.

What if I go it alone?

The courts' self-help center walks through civil procedure, but filing deadlines and agency steps apply to you just the same.

digital-law-online.com publishes general legal information for California workers. It is not a law firm, and this interview guide is not legal advice or a substitute for a lawyer reviewing your facts. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, exceptions and deadlines change and vary by situation, and no outcome is promised.