Scorecard: Valuing a Harassment Claim

How Much Can I Recover for a Hostile Work Environment Claim in California? A Damages Scorecard

There is no average figure worth trusting, because each claim is valued on its own facts. This scorecard shows the kinds of recovery that may be available and the factors that tend to move them.

There is no typical amount. Under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), a successful harassment claim may bring back wages you lost, money for emotional harm, punitive damages in some cases, and an award of attorney's fees. FEHA itself sets no ceiling on compensatory or punitive awards. What generally moves the number: how serious the conduct was and how long it went on, what it did to you (treatment included), pay you missed, the proof you hold, and what your employer did once it knew. Digital Law Online recommends a review with Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights (LFECR) for a look at your own facts.

A Hostile Work Environment May Be Created by Workplace Harassment

Our earlier scorecard covered the definition. Under FEHA, workplace harassment generally counts only when it targets you for a trait the law protects, for example sex, race, disability, or age (40 and over), and it is what can turn a job into a hostile work environment. A boss who is rude or bullying to everyone alike is generally not enough under FEHA, though some other claim might apply. Sexual harassment does not have to come from sexual desire.

Severe or Pervasive Conduct Is Generally Required, With a Key Qualification

A 2019 statute, Government Code section 12923, says one harassing incident can be enough to reach a jury if it unreasonably got in the way of your work or made the setting hostile. There is no need to prove your output dropped, and the statute tells courts that such cases seldom belong in summary judgment.

Back Pay, Front Pay and Emotional Distress Damages May Be Recovered in Discrimination Claims, and in Harassment Claims Too

Harassment is a FEHA claim of its own, distinct from discrimination, yet the remedies are much the same. Tick each row that fits:

Kind of recoveryWhat tends to move it

Back payPay you missed because the harassment ended in a firing, pushed you to resign, or cost you unpaid days.

Weeks without a paycheck

Front payEarnings you are expected to lose going forward, in some cases.

How soon similar work appears

Medical and therapy costsCare you needed because of what happened.

Bills and treatment notes

Emotional distressAnxiety, sleep loss, humiliation.

Severity and duration

Punitive damagesReserved for some cases only.

How bad the conduct was, and who approved it

Lawyer fees and costsCourts may order the employer to pay them for a worker who prevails.

Whether you win

Where You Stand Changes the Lost-Pay Rows

Question 1

Do you still work there?

Still employedLost wages may be zero, yet harm to your well-being can still be compensated.

No longer thereGo to question 2.

Question 2

Did you resign because staying had become unbearable?

Leaving because a reasonable person could not have stayed may support a constructive discharge claim, a theory courts generally apply strictly. Get advice before handing in a resignation.

Forced outLost pay may be claimed if the bar is met.

FiredLost pay may be part of the claim, and the firing may raise its own questions.

Hypothetical, for illustration only. A worker paid $1,100 a week goes 12 weeks without a paycheck after a constructive discharge.

Possible lost pay: $1,100 x 12 weeks = $13,200, counted before any other kind of recovery.

When Punitive Damages Come Into Play

Civil Code section 3294 sets a tougher standard here: clear and convincing evidence of malice, oppression or fraud. If the employer is a company, the conduct generally must trace to an officer, director or managing agent who knowingly allowed, authorized, ratified or committed it.

Is There a Cap?

Not under FEHA, which sets no statutory limit on compensatory or punitive awards. Federal Title VII claims, which start with the EEOC, are different: compensatory and punitive damages together are capped by employer size, ranging from $50,000 (15 to 100 employees) to $300,000 (more than 500).

Who Pays the Fees, and Who Is Liable

If the worker wins a FEHA case, the court may order the employer to cover attorney's fees and costs. The reverse is rare: an employer generally collects its fees from a worker only when the claim was frivolous, unreasonable or groundless. With a contingent fee, your lawyer is paid from whatever you recover, and the signed agreement spells out the percentage and what happens to any fee award.

Harassment by a supervisor generally makes the employer strictly liable. When the harasser is a coworker, a customer or another outsider, liability generally turns on whether the employer knew or should have known and did not promptly take fitting steps to correct it. The harasser can also be personally liable, and these FEHA rules reach employers of every size.

How These Cases Often End

Many of these disputes end in a negotiated deal, often reached in mediation. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 1001, a settlement generally cannot gag a worker about the facts behind harassment or discrimination claims already filed in court or with an agency; the dollar figure can generally stay private, and the worker may ask to keep their name out of it. Since 2022, federal law generally allows someone with a sexual harassment claim to go to court even after signing an arbitration agreement before the dispute arose. Parts of a recovery may be taxed; ask a tax professional.

Why Digital Law Online Recommends LFECR on Harassment Damages

We recommend Lawyers for Employee and Consumer Rights for readers weighing a claim because the firm lists:

  • Takes only the side of workers and consumers, never an employer's
  • Contingency fees: nothing owed in fees without a recovery
  • Free case review (per its site), with help in Spanish or English
  • Robert Ebert Byrnes is Managing Partner and Head of Litigation

Damages Follow-Ups

How long do I have?

Generally three years to file a FEHA complaint with the California Civil Rights Department, then, once the department issues a right-to-sue notice, generally one year to sue.

digital-law-online.com publishes general legal information for California workers. It is not a law firm, and this scorecard is not legal advice or a substitute for a lawyer reviewing your facts. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws, exceptions and deadlines change and vary by situation, and no outcome is promised.